THE NORTH END/SOUTH END RIVALRY OF TORONTO, OHIO
More than the most common street
name in the United States, Main Street of Toronto, Ohio has a most uncommon
distinction, and might as well at one time have been the Mason-Dixon Line, or
the Center of the Universe, as some Torontonians thought and still think; such was
the rivalry between the North End and the South End of the Gem City.
Although some Toronto residents have
always disputed the true demarcation separating the town’s north from the
south, Main Street marks the boundary between Knox Township on the north and
Island Creek on the other side of the street.
No one, to this writer’s knowledge, from the City of Vision has ever publicly
called himself a Knoxer or an Island Creeker; always a South-ender or a North-ender,
or even a North-end Hunky, even those not of Slavic heritage.
The term “Hunky,” in fact, was an
ethnic slur, whose origin predated the turn of the 20th Century and
referred to Slovak and other Slavs who had emigrated to the U.S. to escape the
oppressive rule of the Austro-Hungarian Empire, a reign that forbid Slovaks to
teach their own language. Although their
native land was Slovakia, their official entry papers listed them as immigrants
from Hungary, and hence the ethnic slur, “Hunky.” The Toronto Slovaks congregated in the north
end of Toronto where an abundance of job opportunities attracted them, jobs
with low pay and long hours, this tenure often requiring them to work 32
consecutive hours.
My Slovak grandparents told me
stories about prejudice toward Slavs back then, told me why they did not pass
on their Eastern Slovak dialect onto their children and grandchildren, that
they did not want them to grow up with accents and become targets of prejudice
and derision. My grandfather John Petras
Sr. told me a story about the Ku Klux Klan marching up and down Loretta Avenue in
1935, and while standing upon his front porch, he shook his fist at one
Klansman, recognizing him by his peculiar gait, and saying, “I know who you are,
Charlie. You look ridiculous!” As the robes continued down street, he
shouted again, “And by the way, Notre Dame will beat Ohio State again this
season!” And the Fighting Irish did—7
to 2.
Back then Slavs were distinguished
as a separate race. Hitler wanted to eradicate
them, and back home, if they held a position in City Hall, it was on their
knees, scrubbing it. In “Out of This
Furnace,” a novel about an immigrant Slovak family—the Dobrejcaks—author Thomas
Bell wrote that most Americans did not consider Eastern Europeans, such as
Slovaks and Poles, as well as Southern Europeans, like Italians, white.
In 1935, the same year as the Klan
March, the racial tensions came to an ugly climax April 17, four days before
Easter, when pickets at the perimeter of Kaul Clay, the majority of which were
of Slavic descent and other minorities, met a storm of gunfire from Pinkerton
Detectives, resulting in one death and another four wounded. The fatality was Andy Lastivka, a Slovak
whose residence stood two blocks from where he had fallen. Another Toronto Slovak, Andy Straka, carried a
Pinkerton slug in his leg for life. No
one was ever arrested or convicted for the shootings.
Even to this day, one can see the
stigma of prejudice by touring Union Cemetery and the headstones in the oldest
section to discover not a soul of Slavic or Southeastern European descent
buried amongst the obelisks and monuments dedicated to the Masons and other
prominent residents of a municipality nicknamed the Gem City. Union Cemetery was a site frequently marched
by the Klan, often numbering more than 50 hoods.
If Time is a great healer, it is
because it is a great inducer of forgetfulness.
Gradually, the wounds of this culture clash became subsumed into oblivion. North-enders moved southward, the direction
by which the expanding city grew.
South-enders moved north. Slavic
names blended into a hodgepodge with those of Irish, Scottish, German, Anglo,
Italian and others. They
intermarried. And World War II united
everyone.
Second and third generation Slavs
married sons and daughters of Toronto’s founding fathers, one of whom was
Revolutionary War scout and Indian fighter Michael Myers, who had 11 children
with his wife Katherine Strickler, and the Auver rumored to have fathered
more. It has been said by more than a
few T-town old-timers that half the town is descended from a dude who lived to
a ripe old age of 107 years while the other half is of Slovak descent. Said more bluntly: half the town is related;
the other half doesn’t know it. Perhaps that is the reason the north end-south
end rivalry eventually became reduced to brotherly banter and that, too, has faded.
There are some striking geographical
and demographic features distinguishing the two half-cities. For the most part, the North End is flat, the
streets straight while the South End is hilly, the streets often curvy. The North End is overlooked by Meyers Knob,
part of the Pennsylvanian Escarpment, the South End overlooked by a geological
anomaly, Mount Nebo, where the Ohio River once flowed on the west of the
mountain, the floodplain that is Walton Acres today. In geological terms, it is
classified as Wisconsinian. There were
the clay works and the power plant in the Mosti side of town and the paper
mill, block factory and Titanium in the Coulters side ; Rudy’s in the north and
Melhorn’s and Happy’s south; the Power Plant houses in the north, the Mill Row
south; and the North End Tavern in the draft root beer side of town, the South
End Tavern in the Goonie Burger side, or simply called Skunk’s if you didn’t give
a flying river rat’s ass about zonal distinctions.
Even the currents of the Ohio are
claimed by some to flow funny below Main Street.
An old Kaul Clay veteran, a Hunky at
heart, once exclaimed that City Hall had a conspiracy to move everything important
in T-town south of Main Street. Maybe
there was a conspiracy, looking back, now that every grade school, K through 12,
sits on one site. (Rumor says this
conspiracy began when the color blue initially appeared in Red Knight
uniforms.). The north-end and
Slovak-language teaching parochial school St. Jopeph’s merged south with St.
Francis until that, too, merged with oblivion, like Slovak Days, which incinerated
into nothingness when Kaul Hall along Croxton’s Run Road burned to the ground
in the 1970s.
And the south end holds a wide margin in this pizza-consuming town of a
four to one margin, a town further divided by loyalties to a square pie, and
like an Ivy League rivalry in which you are a staunch Harvard man or a Yale
man, in T-town you can distinguish oneself as an Iggy’s man or a Dicarlo’s or Domino’s
dude, a Gem City Pizza gal or one of the diminishing few, the most loyal of the
loyal, still holding out for the return of Johnny’s.
An interesting fact about the pizza
logistics of the Gem City is that the town never has had a pizza shop operated
its ovens north of Clark Street, not even the fabled monopolistic Johnny’s,
which moved from site to site as often Bill Jaco, always in the South End.
Some
dispute, until this day, occurs about the true line separating the two halves
of the city. Some claim as far north as
Myers while some say the south end begins at the Overhead Bridge. And then there is the mythical midtown, a
so-called neutral zone from Main to Clarke.
In truth, to the best of this Iggy’s man and anti-blue bring-back-the-Goonie
advocate, and based on personal bar- and- tavern on-the-site research, no such establishment
has been named anything close to “Midtown Bar” while there has been fierce patronage for decades
at the aforementioned North End and South End Taverns, the mythical midtown
home to such neutrally named watering holes as the City Restaurant, Frogs and
Gem City Restaurant, unless, of course, “Candyland” was some secret blue conspiracy
code name for the “Center of the City Fish Bowl.”
Perhaps,
the north-south T-town rivalry became extinct at the advent of open enrollment. Maybe too many Cernanskys and Scalleys moved
south. Who knows? Ask the millennial and younger T-towners
about the north end-south end rivalry and they’ll probably respond by asking if
that’s a new video game.
This
town’s north end-south end rivalry is gone, faded like the advertising on the
Daniels Building, memory-aided, barely discernible but to some. Toronto, Ohio is one town, as it should be, a
small city, as it has become, a hometown, always.
